In late February, the owner of a sushi and Asian bistro in Jacksonville Beach, Florida, pleaded guilty to federal charges for knowingly employing undocumented workers for personal gain. The charges followed an investigation by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and could result in a sentence of up to ten years in prison.
While this is just one case, it represents a growing pattern of federal immigration enforcement that’s putting restaurant owners and operators across the country on high alert. The hospitality industry, long known for its reliance on immigrant labor, now faces renewed scrutiny, and many businesses are unprepared for what a surprise audit or workplace raid could mean.
The U.S. Center for Migration Studies estimates that about one million undocumented individuals are currently employed in the restaurant sector. That’s a substantial portion of the workforce—and a clear signal to federal agencies that the industry is worth targeting.
The good news: restaurant operators can take proactive steps to protect their businesses, stay compliant, and respond appropriately if faced with ICE activity. This guide offers practical, legal, and operational advice to help you stay ready.
Understanding Why Restaurants Are Vulnerable
Restaurants are particularly exposed to immigration enforcement actions for several key reasons:
- Heavy reliance on immigrant labor:
The restaurant industry depends heavily on immigrant workers to fill essential roles such as dishwashers, prep cooks, line staff, and delivery drivers. Many of these positions are physically demanding, low-paying, and hard to fill with native-born workers, making them particularly attractive to recent immigrants. In some cases, employees may not have legal work authorization, which increases the risk of violations during audits or raids by immigration authorities. - Rapid hiring processes:
Due to high turnover rates and the urgent need to staff kitchens and front-of-house positions, restaurant operators often prioritize speed over thoroughness when hiring. This can lead to shortcuts in onboarding procedures, such as failing to verify documents properly through E-Verify or neglecting to maintain accurate I-9 forms. As a result, restaurants may unknowingly employ unauthorized workers, leaving them exposed to enforcement actions. - Small business structure:
Many independent or family-owned restaurants operate with limited administrative resources. Without dedicated HR personnel or legal teams, these businesses often lack the infrastructure to maintain consistent compliance with complex immigration regulations. Documentation may be handled informally or inconsistently, making it easy for gaps or errors to occur that could attract the attention of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) or the Department of Labor.
These realities create vulnerabilities that make it easier for federal authorities to identify potential violations—and more difficult for owners to prove they were operating in good faith.
Step 1: Know the Law—And What to Do If ICE Shows Up
If ICE agents arrive at your business, it’s essential to know your rights—and the limits of their authority.
What to Ask For:
- Demand a judicial warrant
ICE officers must present a warrant signed by a judge to enter non-public areas of your restaurant or conduct a search. A warrant signed by an ICE officer or supervisor does not count as judicial and is not legally enforceable in the same way. - Review the warrant’s contents
- Is your business or a specific individual named?
- Is the warrant signed and dated by a judge?
- Is the scope of the search clearly outlined?
- Is your business or a specific individual named?
- Do not allow access without proper documentation
If ICE cannot present a valid judicial warrant, you are within your rights to deny entry to areas not open to the public (e.g., kitchen, back office, break room). - Remain calm and refrain from signing anything
Labor and immigration attorney Ian Wagreich emphasizes the importance of not signing any documents before speaking with a lawyer. Some documents may waive your rights—or those of your employees—without you even realizing it. - Document the interaction
Note the names of any agents, their badge numbers, time of arrival, what they asked for, and what they did while on-site.
📌 For more, visit the official ICE Worksite Enforcement page: https://www.ice.gov/worksite
Step 2: Train Your Team and Establish Protocols
A clear and practiced response plan is the best way to minimize disruption if ICE visits your business.
ICE Preparedness Checklist:
- Designate a point person: Choose a manager or trusted staff member who is trained to interact with ICE agents and follow the proper steps.
- Educate your team: Train all employees on their rights and what to do if approached or questioned by agents.
- Post clear protocols in staff-only areas: These should outline how to respond to agents, who to contact, and what steps to follow if a warrant is presented.
- Establish legal counsel: Retain an employment or immigration attorney before a crisis hits. Ideally, this attorney is briefed on your workplace structure and can respond quickly in an emergency.
Employee Rights Every Team Member Should Know:
Regardless of immigration status, every individual has rights under U.S. law, including:
- The right to remain silent
- The right to speak with a lawyer before answering questions or signing documents
- The right to refuse entry without a valid warrant
- The right to contact their consulate
- The right to due process
Empowering your employees with this knowledge not only protects them—it can prevent panic and ensure a smoother, safer interaction with law enforcement.
Step 3: Review and Strengthen Your Hiring Practices
Hiring undocumented workers—knowingly or not—can expose you to serious legal and financial consequences. Being proactive about your employment verification practices is one of the best ways to reduce risk.
Conduct an Internal I-9 Audit
The Form I-9 is required by federal law for every employee and must be properly completed and maintained. Here’s what to check:
- Do you have a Form I-9 on file for every current employee?
- Were documents reviewed within three business days of hire?
- Are expired or missing records corrected and noted?
- Are corrections dated and signed in accordance with legal guidelines?
🧾 Learn more or download the official Form I-9 here:
👉 https://www.uscis.gov/i-9
Consider E-Verify (if applicable)
E-Verify is a voluntary online system that checks the work eligibility of new hires against federal databases. Some states or contracts may require it, and it can be a useful layer of protection—but it’s not a replacement for I-9 compliance.
Stay Clear of Discrimination
It’s illegal to selectively verify the documents of certain workers based on appearance, ethnicity, or perceived immigration status. Always apply the same verification procedures for every employee to avoid claims of discrimination or document abuse.
Step 4: Stay Up to Date on Legal and Political Changes
Immigration law is a fast-moving and politically charged space. For restaurant owners, staying informed is a non-negotiable—what’s permissible today could be prohibited tomorrow, and enforcement priorities can shift overnight.
Recent Legal Developments
- In 2024, several attempts were made to reintroduce aggressive immigration policies, including the revival of the Alien Enemies Act of 1798—a long-dormant law that would have allowed for the mass deportation of certain migrant groups with minimal legal recourse. These efforts sparked widespread concern across the business community, especially in industries like hospitality that depend heavily on immigrant labor. Fortunately, federal courts intervened to block the enforcement of this proposal—for now.
- This ongoing push-and-pull between executive action and judicial oversight highlights a key reality: immigration enforcement is not just a legal issue; it’s a political one. As leadership in Washington changes—or as new court decisions are handed down—employers must be ready to adapt quickly.
What It Means for You
✅ Stay informed about changes in enforcement strategy:
Monitor developments in federal, state, and local policy. What ICE prioritizes one year may shift the next, especially during election cycles or amid national security concerns.
✅ Join local business associations or industry groups for updates and resources:
Organizations like your city’s restaurant association or hospitality chamber often provide timely alerts, webinars, and legal insights to help members stay ahead of new rules and risks.
✅ Maintain regular communication with your legal advisors:
Don’t wait until a crisis hits. Schedule check-ins with your employment or immigration attorney to review your current practices, clarify any gray areas, and ensure your documentation processes are airtight.
✅ Consider assigning a compliance lead:
Whether it’s a general manager or an external consultant, having someone dedicated to monitoring legal updates and overseeing implementation across your team can save you from costly oversights.
Step 5: Build a Culture of Compliance and Care
Your workplace culture can be one of your strongest defenses during times of uncertainty. By fostering an environment rooted in transparency, respect, and legal compliance, you send a clear message—to both your team and outside authorities—that your business operates with integrity and accountability. This isn’t just about risk management—it’s about leadership.
Transparency with Employees
Let your staff know that you are committed to following the law while also protecting their dignity and rights. Open, honest communication helps build trust and reduces fear or confusion if enforcement actions do occur.
Reassure your team that being proactive about compliance is not about targeting individuals—it’s about creating a safe, secure, and lawful environment for everyone. For example, clearly explaining what documents are required during hiring and why helps prevent misunderstandings and reinforces your commitment to fair practices.
Consider holding regular meetings or trainings where employees can ask questions and share concerns in a safe space. When workers feel informed and respected, they’re more likely to cooperate, stay loyal, and help maintain compliance from within.
Connect with Community Resources
You don’t have to go it alone. Many nonprofit organizations, immigrant advocacy groups, and legal clinics offer resources specifically designed for businesses that employ immigrant workers. These include:
- Legal workshops that walk through your rights and responsibilities as an employer
- Know Your Rights trainings for staff, so they know what to do if immigration authorities arrive
- Emergency preparedness plans to guide you through audits, site visits, or sudden policy changes
Partnering with these organizations not only equips your business with practical tools, but also demonstrates to your employees and the wider community that you’re serious about doing the right thing.
Promote a Supportive Culture from the Top Down
Leadership sets the tone. When owners and managers model lawful, respectful behavior and take compliance seriously, it trickles down through the rest of the organization. Celebrate the values of fairness, dignity, and preparedness just as you would celebrate a successful service or positive customer review.
Stay Prepared, Stay Compliant
ICE enforcement activity in the restaurant industry is real—and it’s not going away anytime soon. High-profile cases and increased scrutiny have made it clear: failing to comply with immigration laws can lead to serious legal and financial consequences, including hefty fines, loss of business licenses, and even criminal charges. But the good news is, these outcomes are often preventable with proactive measures and a commitment to compliance.
To recap, here’s how you can protect your business:
✅ Know your rights and how to respond to ICE:
Every business owner and manager should understand what agents can and cannot do during an inspection, audit, or raid. Being informed is your first line of defense.
✅ Train your staff and designate a point person:
Your team should know how to respond calmly and legally in the event of an ICE visit. Assign a trusted staff member or manager as the point of contact to handle interactions and protect your business’s interests.
✅ Audit and maintain I-9 forms regularly:
Keep I-9 documentation complete, organized, and up to date. Schedule internal audits or work with a professional to identify and fix errors before ICE does.
✅ Treat all employees fairly and lawfully:
Avoid discriminatory practices when verifying documents or making employment decisions. Treating workers respectfully and equally isn’t just ethical—it’s also legally required.
✅ Stay current on immigration law and policy changes:
Immigration regulations can change quickly, especially with shifting political climates. Stay connected with legal counsel or industry associations to stay ahead of new requirements and best practices.
Taking action now means peace of mind later. By building a culture of compliance and staying informed, you not only safeguard your restaurant from enforcement risks—you also create a more stable, ethical, and resilient workplace for everyone involved. Your employees, your reputation, and your livelihood depend on it.
Final Thoughts:
And as you work to ensure full compliance across your operation, remember the importance of certifications and industry credentials. Whether you’re training new staff, preparing for a health inspection, or getting ready for legal testimony, having the right support can make all the difference. Ken Kuscher offers food handler certification programs and expert witness services tailored specifically for professionals in the food service industry. With years of hands-on experience and a deep understanding of regulatory standards, Ken is a trusted partner in helping operators stay compliant, reduce risk, and uphold the highest standards of safety and accountability. Don’t leave your compliance to chance—partner with an expert who knows what it takes to protect your business and your reputation.
Florida Food Handler Certificates
Avoid fines by ordering your Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation-approved Food Worker Program certificates today. They’re available for just $4 each. Program #5552749.
Place your order online here. For additional information, you can call (561) 703-7196.
As a Rule 702-qualified expert witness with nearly 40 years of experience in food safety, sanitation, and regulatory compliance, I provide expert testimony, case analysis, and legal consultation for attorneys, businesses, and matters involving regulatory agencies.
***Please note that the insightful and engaging content provided on our platform is crafted by our dedicated Marketing Department’s content writing team. While Ken Kuscher is the esteemed figure and expert within our industry, the articles and blog posts available are not personally authored by Ken.
